VALID Tree Risk Assessments for Northern Ireland Councils
Public parks and woodlands provide enormous benefits. Managing their trees responsibly means recognising those benefits alongside the risk.
Written by John McNamara, arboricultural consultant, McNamara Tree Consultancy. A VALID Accredited Validator and Registered QTRA User who also holds Professional Tree Inspection (PTI) certification and is an Associate Member of the Arboricultural Association. View John's qualifications and experience

Public parks and woodlands provide enormous benefits. Managing their trees responsibly means recognising those benefits alongside the risk, and recommending work where there is a sound reason for it.
Each year, I carry out VALID Tree Risk-Benefit Assessments for Fermanagh and Omagh District Council, Ards and North Down Borough Council, and Mid and East Antrim Borough Council. These assessments cover a range of public sites, typically including large parks and public woodlands.
The way people use each site matters. A tree beside a busy path presents a different assessment from a similar tree in a quiet woodland corner. The presence of decay, deadwood or another feature needs to be considered in that context.
VALID provides a structured approach to balancing the risk posed by trees with the benefits they provide. It uses a probabilistic framework to keep decisions proportionate, helping clients distinguish between work that is justified and work driven by an exaggerated perception of danger.
That distinction can substantially reduce unnecessary tree works and their associated costs, while retaining trees that continue to contribute to the landscape, biodiversity and public enjoyment.
As an independent arboricultural consultant, I do not carry out tree surgery. There is no financial incentive for me to recommend pruning or removal.
The purpose is straightforward: give councils clear, practical information so they can manage their trees confidently, direct resources towards justified work and retain valuable trees wherever reasonably possible.
Our preference at McNamara Tree Consultancy is to use VALID, which we believe is the most modern risk assessment methodology in arboriculture. It is also the easiest to understand for clients and lay people. However, I am a Registered QTRA User and can carry out QTRA assessments for clients who would prefer this method.
