Skip to content

Disputes and claims

Tree Disputes and Expert Witness Reports

Independent arboricultural reports, expert witness evidence and advice for tree boundary disputes, damage claims and planning appeals across Northern Ireland & Ireland.

Independent Reports for Tree Disputes

When a tree becomes the subject of a dispute, opinion is rarely in short supply. What is usually missing is an independent record of the facts: what the tree is, what condition it is in, what happened and what the evidence on site can and cannot tell us.

McNamara Tree Consultancy provides independent arboricultural reports and advice for legal disputes involving trees, and helps with their resolution, across Northern Ireland & Ireland. Every inspection and report is carried out by John McNamara personally.

The report records what was found on site, with photographs and measurements, and keeps what was observed separate from what is professional opinion. Where the evidence does not answer a question, the report says so.

We carry out no tree works. The findings are not shaped by any work that might follow, which matters when a report may be read by the other side, a solicitor, an insurer or a court.

Suitable for

Homeowners and neighboursLandowners and businessesLegal and insurance advisersPlanning appeals
Discuss Your Case

Disputes we are asked about

  • Tree boundary disputes over branches, roots or a tree one side wants removed
  • Damage caused by a fallen tree or branch
  • Deliberate damage to trees
  • Planning appeals where trees are central to the decision
  • Expert witness reports and evidence in court

Who inspects the tree and writes the report?

Dispute reports are inspected and written by John McNamara, an arboriculturist with over 8 years of experience, so the person who examined the tree is the person who answers for the report.

  • Professional Tree Inspection (PTI)
  • VALID Accredited Validator
  • Registered QTRA User
  • Associate Member, Arboricultural Association

View John’s qualifications and experience

The disputes we are asked about

Tree boundary disputes between neighbours. Overhanging branches, roots crossing a boundary, a tree one neighbour wants removed and the other wants kept. We inspect the tree, record its position and condition, and set out what work, if any, is justified.

Damage caused by a fallen tree or branch. John has reported on a case where a tree fell on a car and caused damage. A report of this kind examines the failed tree and the site, and considers how and why the failure happened. Our guide to who is liable when a tree falls explains how responsibility is usually decided.

Deliberate damage to trees. John has assessed a site where trees were set on fire deliberately. A report of this kind records the damage to each tree and what it means for the tree’s future.

Planning appeals. John has represented clients at planning appeals where trees were central to the decision.

Expert witness, court and planning appeals

Where a dispute goes further, John acts as an expert witness. He has given evidence in court and has represented clients at planning appeals. This work is covered by the practice’s professional indemnity insurance.

Before you do anything to the tree

Photograph everything before anything is cut or cleared. If a tree or branch has failed, keep the failed section where it is safe to do so, because it may hold the evidence of why it failed.

Check whether the tree is protected before arranging any work. Our guide to Tree Preservation Orders in Northern Ireland explains how to check, and we prepare tree works applications where consent is needed.

None of this is legal advice. Your solicitor advises on your legal position. Our part is the tree: an honest, recorded assessment that both sides can read.

Common questions

Do you carry out the tree work afterwards? No. We survey and report only, so there is no financial interest in what the report recommends.

Will you appear in court? Yes. John acts as an expert witness, has given evidence in court and has represented clients at planning appeals.

Need clear advice before your project moves forward?

Send us your site information and we will help you understand the appropriate next step.